UCHUU SENKAN YAMATO 2202: AI NO SENSHI-TACHI

DESCRIPTION

CAST

OVA ActionUchuu Senkan Yamato 2199
OVA ActionUchuu Senkan Yamato 2205: Aratanaru Tabidachi
MOVIE Action"Uchuu Senkan Yamato" to Iu Jidai: Seireki 2202-nen no Sentaku

REVIEWS

• 

  Scheveningen

  55/100
  An ambitious sequel that has entertaining spectacle but a great deal of failings compared to the original

  While Space Battleship Yamato 2202: Warriors of Love does still continues to carry the spirit of the original series, it starts to falter under the weight of that legacy, failing to adequately adapt and modernise it for a new era. As a sequel to 2199, the only strength it really carries forward is the fantastic visuals and models for its ship to ship combat. But aside from spectacle, it falters heavily in terms of its plot, themes, characters, and at times, even comprehensibility.

  The most apparent issue with Warriors of Love is the extreme plot bloat that only heightens the convoluted nature of its central themes. While 2199 was fairly concentrated, with only two significant subplots that eventually tied into their journey to Iscandar, 2202 has arguably four or even five of these crammed into the same space. This leaves some of their themes like the proliferation of Wave Motion weaponry and the question of integrating AI control on Earth's warships woefully underserved. Warriors of Love does raise interesting questions with a thematic resonance with the rest of the franchise, yet it never has the time to deal with them. The inclusion of Teresa ends up being more of a plot catalyst than an actual plot point, an excuse to dump exposition and prepare for a deus ex machina than anything that furthers the themes of arcs of the characters. The need to adhere to this element from the original Space Battleship Yamato II hamstrings a plot that should be focused elsewhere. Probably entirely on the conflict with the Gatlantians and their attack on Earth. In fact, it sacrifices a lot of the time its predecessor 2199 spent developing their characters to cater to the myriad of plot threads. This presents a fundamental problem since character development was mainly done in smaller, more contained stories that buttressed the central plot. That was how 2199 handled a chunk of its episodes which eased the show's pacing and added an emotional depth to the stakes. Warriors of Love adds more characters to the cast while being forced to use its time outside the central narrative to attempt to flesh out its side plots. Even writing out some of the Yamato secondary crew early on in the season does not alleviate the pressure for screen time. As a result, none of its new or old characters feels particularly well developed, and the sheer number of subplots ensure that none get enough time to fully realise their potential.

  This general overload spills into its frankly confusing central thesis of questioning what makes a being "human". While the general idea of the emotional experience being a powerful and core part of human existence is eventually put across, it is done in such a convoluted manner that it undermines its already very irrational premise. The use of irrational here is not meant to be pejorative, but rather its literal meaning in that it hinges on the lived experience instead of any cerebral philosophical basis. The problem lies in that 2202 does not let their character's motivations and conflict carry this emotional thesis across but instead tries to deliver it like an intellectual one. You can have your characters debate and agonise over something like deploying the Wave Motion Gun since it is an ethical quandary. On the other hand, something as intangible as love and its meaning or as a source of motivation is something that must be more parts demonstrated than debated. All Zwoder's rambling does is obfuscate and convolute the relatively simple point he is making and drag it into the depths of melodrama. The irony is that there are already stronger character moments that demonstrate this on screen. Kato's pain of having to choose between his duty or his sick son embodies one of the central themes of 2202. That love is both a great motivator but also an incredible source of pain, and that this emotional experience is integral to understanding being human. Yet the outstanding character moments with Kaot are a mere subplot and never replicated in other areas. Warriors of Love seems either deeply insecure about how simply its idea can be put across or really does think in such a self-aggrandising way. And neither reflect very well on its construction.

  Translating back to the characters, this also means that all of them either stagnate or are incredibly shallow. None of the characters are leveraged to dig into the theme of love and emotions being central to human existence. Instead, they constantly veer into melodrama since the show never develops their motivations clearly and only uses their actions as means to further the plot instead of demonstrate anything about their character. In particular, the reintroduction of Desler is done in both a hamfisted and contrived manner that only tangentially ties into an examination of what people will do for love or in an emotional state. So much of 2202's run time is spent trying to clumsily recontextualise Desler's actions from 2199 that it feels closer to a retcon than being presented with a different perspective. Barely any of this was set up in 2199, and sadly, Warriors of Love does not earn enough goodwill with the viewer to have them give it the benefit of the doubt and accept the changes. Nor does 2202 reward anyone who does overlook this since the radical changes to Desler does not add any substantial value to the plot or themes of the story. Again, these all feel like inclusions for the sake of drawing plot elements from the originals without effectively integrating them. Sadly, it just comes out as a confusing eclectic mess that is only saved by its still impressive spectacle and the viewer's pre-established connection to the characters.

  Even then, the spectacle of the massive battles veers from exaggerated into ridiculous at times due to the endless escalation of things. The only battle which does not suffer from this is the opening engagement between the Gatlantians and the combined Earth-Gamilan fleet. There is still a sense of manoeuvring and gradual attrition on both sides, with the fleets maintaining formation. The scale of the battle with the number of ships involved was already verging on being unwieldy, but the focus on the Yunagi and Kodai's actions kept it in check. 2202 then repeatedly jumps the shark by attempting to outdo its previous battles in terms of scale and spectacle. While it is initially visually impressive to see hundreds of ships endlessly fire at each other, it soon loses its lustre and becomes a mind-numbing experience. Without any narrative focal point in the battle, it is just ultimately a series of explosions that reduce to nothing more than eye candy. While that is important for any action show, it cannot fully compensate for its other failings.

  What makes this worse is the scale of the battle, and the weapons employed start to shatter the viewer's sense of disbelief. The Karakum-class Battleship is already shown to be a colossal vessel that dwarfs other battleships. To then immediately raise the stakes by having the Gatlantian fleet be comprised of literally thousands of them makes it hard to take seriously. Part of what creates a convincing fleet engagement is the variety of ships present. Just having walls and walls of one ridiculously large ship class flood into the battle feels simply uninspired and absurd. Again, the irony is that 2199 knew how to write excellent naval engagements and understood that merely increasing the scale endlessly did not necessarily increase tension. The battle at Balun in 2199 appropriately only occurs late into the season. Even then, the writer and director knew not to let the spectacle of thousands of ships attacking the Yamato overstay its welcome. There is an understanding that spectacle can only hold for so long before viewers lose interest, which 2202 seems to enjoy testing the limits of. Ship to ship combat is at its best when there are fewer vessels that undertake more intricate action. Again, the irony is that 2199 already did this well with the excellent battle of the Rainbow Star Cluster, which only involves six ships and their air wings. The viewer can follow a sense of tension, stakes, move and counter move. Warriors of Love going in the exact opposite direction is a tragic disappointment that is only compounded by knowing how well its predecessor executed their action scenes.

  On the more technical front, Warriors of Loves fails to balance the campy retro origins of many of its ship designs and ideas with more modern, "harder" sci-fi interpretations. Some elements are adapted well enough, like the asteroid shield from the original series being written in as a legacy of the Izumo plan. Others like the Karakum-class sits on the knife's edge of this, having exaggerated features like its main mast being literally three turrets stacked on top of each other. This finally goes into the territory of the plain absurd when they introduce the Gatlantian supercarrier that launches its planes by spinning its flight decks like a drill. There is no logical reason for this, and it looks ridiculous. This shatters the suspension of disbelief since it undermines the spectacle of the action while drawing attention to the fact that so many of these designs already bordered on the insane or even plain stupid. This was already a mild issue in 2199 with the idea of battle carriers and the four decked carriers that obviously lacked the appropriate internal volume to house the rest of the ship's systems. However, the strengths of 2199's other elements allowed it to be handwaved and viewed as an exaggerated stylistic design instead of absurdity. A similar problem can be found in the Gatlantian battle tactics, with their Legionary Cannon being a formation ships circling each other in a cylinder to somehow create a concentrated energy beam being absolutely ridiculous. This pushes the boundary of what is already closer to space fantasy and into the realm of pure camp. It undoes so much of the serious tone and effort put into the technobabble by showing battle scenes that are so detached from any semblance of sense. It discards the suspension of disbelief that 2199 earns by mirroring naval combat and goes straight into the epitome of appearance over substance by coming up with wild detached ideas.

  But perhaps worst of all is the mass proliferation of Wave Motion Guns. While it is an impressive sight to see a whole volley of them being fired, it actively cheapens one of the central themes of Space Battleship Yamato. Wave Motion weapons become a dime a dozen and are shown to have mostly middling power and effectiveness. This undermines the idea that it is a dangerous power that the cast of Space Battleship Yamato bares a heavy heart whenever utilising. When combined with the general lack of debate over the Wave Motion fleet's use, implications, or ethics, it significantly detracts from 2202's thematic strength. It feels almost like it is spitting in the face of one of the strongest points of 2199 just for the sake of spectacle and leaves Warriors of Love feeling even more like melodrama dressed up with action. While 2199 balances out the strengths and weaknesses of a space opera, 2202 seems to dive headlong into the genre's pitfalls. Sadly, the strengths 2202 brings to the table, like the interesting ideas presented by the inclusion of the Ginga are not developed enough to compensate for this. And while the action involving the CRS and the Black Bird technology is creative and engaging, it does not make up for the other elements lost in 2202's breakneck escalation of scale.

  Overall, Warriors of Love is a disappointing sequel that devolves into a convoluted mess. It attempts to do too much and hamstrings its own central themes by aggrandising what is a simple idea. Love and emotional attachment has the potential to resonate with viewers more than more distant concepts like duty, heroism, or the moral burden of war. Yet its contrived delivery and mess of multiple plot threads make its theme of love either incomprehensible or hard to take seriously. This thematic weakness (made worse by its casual use of Wave Motion guns that retroactively cheapen even 2199) is barely propped up by the spectacle and emotional scenes. The latter are few and far between and are achieved mainly due to the viewer's investment in characters from 2199 than any new developments. It is still technically competent, and the spectacle is undeniably entertaining, at least initially, and if only for what it shows than any of its implications. Yet it fails so drastically in other areas that it is hard to give it a 6. On the other hand, a 4 feels too harsh since the show is still comprehensible and eventually gets its point across. Objectively, Warriors of Love is likely a 5.5 out of 10. Not due to its mediocrity but due to its fundamental problems in certain areas. Yet it still can keep a viewer invested through its initial hooks, unlike other shows that lose their audience. And even a frustrated viewer will still be inclined to stick around to the end, strung along by the action and the hopes of finally comprehending the motives and themes of Zworder. Sadly, with how the rating system is, Space Battleship Yamato 2202: Warriors of Love is far closer to a 5 with all its problems than a 6. I would still recommend this to fans of 2199, but only them. At the very least, it will present some good combat scenes and enough context to watch 2205, which will hopefully be better.

  Continue on AniList

SIMILAR ANIMES YOU MAY LIKE

• OVA

  DramaGinga Eiyuu Densetsu
• ANIME

  ActionSeikai no Senki
• OVA

  ActionKidou Senshi Gundam: THE ORIGIN
• ANIME

  ActionChoujikuu Yousai Macross
• ANIME

  DramaUchuu Senkan Yamato 2
• ANIME

  AdventureGinga Tetsudou 999